Loading
The Right Against Self-Incrimination: A Privacy-Legally Debate
Author
Jayashri Das
Specifications
  • ISBN 13 : 9789382823605
  • year : 2018
  • language : English
  • binding : Hardbound
Description
Contents: 1. Introduction. 2. Testimonial Compulsion and Self–Incrimination Under the Constitution of India. 3. Provisions of Self-Incrimination in Some Other Countries of the World. 4. Evidential Aspect. 5. Judicial Decisions Relating to Evidential Aspect in Indian Perspective. 6. Privacy-Legality Debate in the Law Relating to Self-Incrimination. 7. Findings and Conclusion. The right against self –incrimination is one the basic tenet of adversarial criminal justice system. The burden of proof beyond reasonable doubt rests on the prosecution and accused cannot be compelled to give evidence against him. This constitutional protection may at many times obstruct effective administration of criminal justice as criminals are very hard nut to crack. Hardcore offenders are very often getting off scot free due to lack of evidence of commission of crime. In economic offences, drug trafficking, terrorism and like other high profile cases the perpetrator of the crime uses advanced technology where the conventional methodsused by the state to investigate and detect crime seems to be insufficient. Over and above the plea of self-incrimination and the right to remain silent further restricts the power of investigation of the State. The invention and use of modern scientific investigation techniques have facilitated state to collect evidence in crimes. But legality and validity of these techniques has to be tested constitutionally. The right against self-incrimination is sacrosanct and various aspects of this right has been discussed in this book in detail along with comparative study of selected other countries of the world. The obvious fact is to reconcile two conflicting interests i.e. preservation of human privacy and the interest of the state to prevent crime. What is needed is proper understanding of the techniques of brain-fingerprinting, narcoanalysis, polygraph and DNA examination and how does this may help in identifying crime without violating the constitutional protection against self-incrimination. The present work throws light on evidential value, admissibility and reliability of scientific evidence in relation to right against self-incrimination under the Constitution of India.